Stockle - the stock oracle

TRI VALLEY CORP

US:TVLYQ
No current share price held for this company.

Past year: ▼ 94%(1.00c – 22.0c USD)

Market cap
—
Shares on issue
—
Story beats
31 since 2003
Last event
9 Aug 2012

History

A Bakersfield oil driller that dabbled in Alaskan and Californian minerals ran short of capital, leaned on its own chairman for loans, and filed for Chapter 11 in August 2012.

2003-2006: Listing, restatement and a push into new assets

Tri-Valley Corp's securities were cleared to trade on the American Stock Exchange in October 2003. The company, a Delaware corporation drilling from Bakersfield, California since 1963, soon had to correct itself. In November 2004 it told investors not to rely on its 2003 accounts or the first two quarters of 2004. Testing of its internal controls showed it had booked turnkey drilling money (cash from partners paying for wells) before the wells were finished. About $704,000 of 2003 profit moved into 2004, and a $442,000 cost on the Ekho well had been charged twice. Cash was unaffected and the auditor agreed.

In 2005 the company widened its reach. In May it bought Pleasant Valley Energy from Petrawest for 200,000 shares plus $500,000 cash for a net profits interest, gaining undeveloped California oil leases it had to spend $5 million developing over two years. These became the Oxnard heavy-oil project. In July its mining subsidiary, Select Resources, bought the idle Admiral Calder calcium carbonate quarry in Alaska from Sealaska for $3 million, only $1 million of it in cash. Later filings said no reserves meeting SEC standards had been established, about $2.7 million of equipment spending would be needed, and holding costs ran about $425,000 a year. In January 2006 it paid $2.85 million cash for the producing Tremblor Valley leases near Bakersfield, its first purchase of production rather than exploration acreage. In November 2006 it sold its half of the Tri-Western quarry venture for $10.2 million net and a Bakersfield industrial property for $3.6 million, bringing in around $12 million.

2007-2009: A quiet record, then a lifeline from the boardroom

The record is quiet for 2007 and 2008. By mid-2009 outside investors were no longer an easy source of money. In July vice chairman G. Thomas Gamble put $1 million into convertible preferred stock at $10 a share, when the common traded at $1.02, with an 8% dividend and warrants over 200,000 shares. In September NYSE Amex warned that shareholders' equity of $5.2 million was below the $6 million minimum for a company with five straight years of losses. The company submitted a recovery plan, and the exchange lifted the deficiency in December.

2010-2011: Dilution, restatement and the sale of minerals

In January 2010 the company raised $7.2 million by placing 5.2 million shares at $1.00 to $2.00 with 75 investors, for working capital and to speed up field development already underway. That month it also bought an extension to May 2010 on the Claflin lease at Edison Field, where an independent engineer credited 2.0 million barrels net of proved oil at shallow depth. In April it raised $5 million at $1.30 a share, with warrants over 2.3 million shares and a clause resetting the price if it later sold stock more cheaply. It also sold a spare steam generator for $700,000.

The clause soon cost it. In July two institutional investors received 842,000 shares for a total of $842 after the stock fell below $1.30. The same month the exchange issued a second equity deficiency notice, with equity at $915,942 in March 2010, though the company pointed to 305 barrels a day from Oxnard. In October Gamble, now chairman, swapped $3.55 million owed to him for preferred shares paying a 10% cash dividend and ranking ahead of the common. In December the company sold Admiral Calder for $2.5 million, ending its calcium carbonate business.

In April 2011 it raised $5.0 million gross by placing 10.1 million shares at $0.50, nearly three times as many shares as the April 2010 raise for the same dollars. In June and July it signed the Richardson gold project deal in Alaska, letting US Gold earn 60% by spending up to $5 million and drilling 30,000 feet, and banked a first $200,000 payment.

In August and October 2011 Gamble lent $150,000 and $1 million, repayable on demand. In October the company voided its 2010 annual accounts and four quarters. The April 2010 offering had been valued $6.5 million too high, its reset warrants should have been carried as liabilities costing $1.8 million more in losses, and $1.7 million of steam generators taken from the TVC OPUS 1 drilling partnership had never been recorded. In November Gamble lent a further $2 million through his family trust, and all $3.15 million was rolled into a secured senior note backed by pledges of both operating subsidiaries and a lien over Claflin. The Oxnard leases were kept out of the collateral.

2012: Default and Chapter 11

In April 2012 the company converted the loans into a $3.3 million senior secured note due April 2013, with a warrant over 3 million shares at $0.19 and a permanent 2% of Claflin oil revenue and 1% from every other lease. Gamble had left the chairmanship in November 2011. Days later it borrowed another $1.5 million from the trust at 14% and spent all of it settling the Hansen lawsuit.

In May the exchange issued a third deficiency notice, with equity at $4.4 million, and cited losses large relative to resources. The company then admitted it was already in default on the March note for missing one month's interest and being unable to pay its debts as they fell due. The trust, owed $4.98 million, reserved all remedies. In June the board chose to delist from NYSE Amex, citing an SEC inquiry into possible securities-law violations and unresolved OPUS partner claims. It took a new $1.35 million line, drawable at the trust's discretion, and retained FTI Consulting.

On 7 August 2012 Tri-Valley, both operating subsidiaries and the TVC OPUS 1 partnership filed for Chapter 11 in Delaware, days after the trust allowed an extra $294,258 of over-line borrowing. The filing was itself a default, making the full $7.2 million owed to the trust immediately payable. Shares on issue stood at 68.0 million at the end of 2012.

Written from the 31 story beats below (2003 to 9 Aug 2012), which come from the company's own announcements and filings.

Beat by beat

The events that changed the company's story, in plain English, each written against everything known about the company at the time. The dot shows whether it was good, bad or neutral for shareholders.

shares on issue market cap (log scale)

201268.0m shares · US$2.0m market cap

  1. 9 Aug

    Tri-Valley, its two operating subsidiaries and the TVC Opus I Drilling Program filed Chapter 11 in Delaware on 7 August 2012, days after the Gamble trust allowed an extra $294,258 over-line borrowing. The filing was a further event of default, making the $7.2 million owed to the trust immediately due.

    bankruptcy or receivership

    68.0m shUS$2.0m
  2. 14 June

    TRI VALLEY CORP's securities were notified for removal from listing and registration on its exchange.

    listing compliance notice

    68.0m shUS$4.8m
  3. 4 June

    The board voted to delist voluntarily from NYSE Amex, with trading expected to end around 25 June, because an ongoing SEC inquiry and unresolved OPUS claims made a compliance plan impracticable. It also took a $1.35 million uncommitted Gamble trust line, with advances at the trust's sole discretion, and retained FTI Consulting.

    listing compliance notice

    68.0m shUS$4.8m
  4. 7 May

    Papered the April loan as a second secured note with a warrant struck at $0.10, and in the same filing admitted it was already in default on the March note for missing one month's interest and for being unable to pay its debts as they fell due. The Gamble trust, owed $4.98 million, reserved every remedy including immediate acceleration; a separate newsletter went to the OPUS drilling partners about settling their claims.

    debt default or forbearance

    68.0m shUS$9.5m
  5. 2 May

    NYSE Amex issued a third deficiency notice and, for the first time, cited not just the $6 million equity shortfall but the rule covering losses so large relative to resources that the exchange doubts a company can continue. Equity was $4.4 million; the objection had moved from a number to the viability of the business.

    listing compliance notice

    68.0m shUS$9.5m
  6. 9 Apr

    Borrowed another $1.5 million from the Gamble trust at 14% on the same collateral, and spent all of it settling the Hansen lawsuit in Ventura County. New money was no longer buying wells, it was paying off litigation.

    debt financing

    68.0m shUS$11.6m
  7. 5 Apr

    Converted the chairman's three demand loans into a $3.3 million senior secured note due April 2013, plus a warrant over 3 million shares at $0.19 and, permanently, 2% of the oil revenue from Claflin and 1% from every other lease. Gamble had by then stepped down as chairman in November 2011, so the company's largest creditor was no longer even at the board table, and it had signed away a slice of its best asset's revenue for good.

    debt financing

    68.0m shUS$11.6m

201167.6m shares · US$12.2m market cap

  1. 17 Nov

    Gamble lent a further $2 million through his family trust at 14%, on condition all $3.15 million be rolled into a secured senior note backed by pledges of both operating subsidiaries, a lien over Claflin and royalty rights on top. An unsecured board member had become a secured creditor with a claim on the company's core asset; the Oxnard leases were deliberately kept out of the collateral.

    debt financing

    67.6m shUS$12.2m
  2. 24 Oct

    Said the 2010 annual report and four quarterly reports could no longer be relied on. The April 2010 offering was overvalued by $6.5 million, its reset warrants should have been liabilities with $1.8 million of losses, and $1.7 million of steam generators bought from the TVC OPUS 1 partnership were never recorded.

    financial restatement

    67.6m shUS$12.2m
  3. 19 Oct

    Chairman G. Thomas Gamble lent the company $150,000 in August and $1 million in October, both repayable the moment he asked and the second at 14% interest. Two at-the-market programmes and a $5 million placement earlier in the year had not been enough; working capital now came from the boardroom on demand terms.

    debt financing

    67.6m shUS$12.2m
  4. 8 July

    Signed the definitive Richardson agreement with US Gold and banked the first $200,000 option payment, with $100,000 due on each anniversary. Confirms the May letter of intent and brings in the company's first outside project money in over a year.

    material agreement

    67.6m shUS$40.6m
  5. 3 June

    Select Resources agreed in principle to let US Gold spend up to $5 million and drill 30,000 feet at the Richardson gold project in Alaska to earn 60% of it. Someone else would pay to test the ground, and Tri-Valley kept 100% if US Gold walked away, which was the right structure for a company that could not fund exploration itself.

    material agreement

    44.7m shUS$30.0m
  6. 21 Apr

    Raised $5.0 million gross, $4.7 million after fees, placing 10.1 million shares at $0.50. It matched the April 2010 raise in dollars but cost nearly three times as many shares, and came with penalty payments of 1% a month if the resale registration slipped.

    capital raising announcement

    44.7m shUS$22.4m

2010

  1. 27 Dec

    Sold the Admiral Calder quarry in Alaska to Columbia River Carbonates for $2.5 million cash, five years after buying it for $3 million and never restarting production. With the Tri-Western sale in 2006 this ends the calcium carbonate business entirely.

    asset acquisition disposition

  2. 6 Oct

    Chairman G. Thomas Gamble swapped $3.55 million the company owed him, an $850,000 loan and $2.7 million for Great Valley Production Services interests, for preferred shares paying a 10% cash dividend and ranking ahead of the common. It removed a cash debt but put its own chairman first in line ahead of ordinary shareholders in any wind-up.

    capital raising announcement

  3. 9 July

    The April placement's price-reset clause bit: two institutional investors, Capital Ventures International and Empery Asset Management, took 842,000 shares for a total of $842 because the stock had fallen below $1.30. Dilution handed over for nothing, and the first visible cost of the terms accepted three months earlier.

    capital raising announcement

  4. 9 July

    NYSE Amex issued a second equity deficiency notice: shareholders' equity had collapsed to $915,942 by March 2010, far worse than the $5.2 million that triggered the first warning in 2009. The company pointed to 305 barrels a day from Oxnard and a recovery to about $4.5 million of equity by June, still short of the $6 million minimum.

    listing compliance notice

  5. 6 Apr

    Raised $5 million from institutional investors at $1.30 a share, with warrants over 2.3 million more shares and, critically, a clause that reset the price if the company later sold stock more cheaply. Also sold a spare steam generator for $700,000 and put the South Belridge and Shields-Arms leases up for sale. The reset clause proves expensive: it triggers near-free share issues in July and forces a restatement in 2011.

    material agreement

  6. 25 Jan

    Bought a year's extension, to May 2010, on the Claflin lease at Edison Field near Bakersfield, which an independent engineer credited with 2.0 million barrels net of proved oil at only 650 to 750 feet depth. The lease had already expired once and will only be held if production starts in time, so this became the company's most urgent operational deadline; Claflin is also the asset later pledged to its chairman's trust.

    material agreement

  7. 11 Jan

    Issued 5,153,332 restricted shares at $1.00 to $2.00 to 75 accredited investors for $7.17 million, with NYSE Amex approval. The money was for working capital and to speed up oil and gas field development already underway.

    capital raising announcement

2009

  1. 4 Dec

    NYSE Amex accepted the recovery plan and lifted the equity deficiency, ending the listing threat raised in September. The reprieve lasted seven months.

    listing compliance notice

  2. 29 Sept

    NYSE Amex warned that shareholders' equity of $5.2 million had fallen below the $6 million minimum required of a company with five straight years of losses, and gave it a month to submit a recovery plan. The first formal signal that the drilling programme had been consuming capital faster than it replaced it.

    listing compliance notice

  3. 6 July

    Vice chairman G. Thomas Gamble put $1 million into convertible preferred stock at $10 a share when the common was trading at $1.02, taking an 8% dividend and warrants over 200,000 shares. With outside placements no longer available at any useful price, a board member became the company's financier, the beginning of a dependence that ends in bankruptcy court three years later.

    capital raising announcement

2006

  1. 21 Nov

    Cashed out of minerals in one week: sold its half of the Tri-Western quarry venture to partner Trans-Western Materials for $10.2 million net and a Bakersfield industrial property to Bakersfield Central Metal for $3.6 million, bringing in around $12 million. Ends the venture begun in 2004, which Select Resources had funded almost single-handedly, and came with a three-year non-compete in Californian carbonate and basalt.

    asset acquisition disposition

  2. 10 Jan

    Paid $2.85 million cash for two producing California leaseholds near Bakersfield, named Tremblor Valley, with seven wells making 40 to 50 barrels a day. The first purchase of production rather than exploration acreage, funded from cash reserves rather than a placement.

    asset acquisition disposition

2005

  1. 28 Sept

    Expanded disclosure on the July 2005 Admiral Calder purchase, with the same $1M cash plus $2M note terms. It adds that no reserves meeting SEC standards have been established, that about $2.7M of equipment spending is estimated before operation, that holding costs are about $425,000 a year, and that the filing itself says it is doubtful the mine could operate at a profit without improvements. The company does not plan to redevelop it now. Sealaska and SeaCal must pay environmental clean-up above $100,000, which the company's assessment puts probably under $25,000.

    asset acquisition disposition

  2. 1 Aug

    Through subsidiary Select Resources, bought the idle Admiral Calder calcium carbonate mine in southeast Alaska from Sealaska and SeaCal on 15 July 2005 for $1,000,000 cash plus a $2,000,000 interest-free note repaid at $200,000 a year over ten years. The filing says there are no immediate redevelopment plans, which adds a mining holding alongside the oil and gas business. (This amendment is later superseded by Amendment No. 2 below.)

    asset acquisition disposition

  3. 21 July

    Mining subsidiary Select Resources bought the idled Admiral Calder calcium carbonate quarry in southeast Alaska from Alaska Native corporation Sealaska for $3 million, only $1 million of it cash with the rest paid at $200,000 a year for a decade. A second, non-oil business line alongside the California drilling.

    asset acquisition disposition

  4. 12 May

    Bought Pleasant Valley Energy from Petrawest for 200,000 shares (worth about $2.5 million) plus $500,000 cash for a net profits interest, gaining undeveloped California oil leases it was obliged to spend $5 million developing over two years. These become the Oxnard heavy-oil project that dominates the company's later story.

    asset acquisition disposition

2004

  1. 22 Nov

    Told investors not to rely on its 2003 accounts or the first two quarters of 2004: internal-controls testing showed it had been booking turnkey drilling money before the wells were actually finished. About $704,000 of 2003 profit moved into 2004, and a $442,000 cost on the Ekho well had been charged twice; cash was unaffected and the auditor agreed with the change.

    financial restatement

2003

  1. 28 Oct

    the American Stock Exchange certified TRI VALLEY CORP's securities for listing, clearing them to begin trading.

    listing compliance notice