Stockle - the stock oracle

FAR EAST ENERGY CORP

US:FEEC
No current share price held for this company.

Past year: ▼ 71%(2.00c – 7.00c USD)

Market cap
—
Shares on issue
—
Story beats
46 since 2002
Last event
10 Nov 2015

History

Far East Energy spent fourteen years and mostly shareholders' money chasing Chinese coalbed methane, never reached commercial production, and collapsed into Chapter 7 liquidation in 2015 owing about $123 million.

2002-2004: Contracts and first wells

Far East Energy set out to find coalbed methane, gas held in coal seams, in China. In June 2002 it signed a joint venture with Panjiang Coal-Electricity to capture gas from six working coal mines over 120 square kilometres, agreeing to pay $3.3 million over three years. In January 2003 China's commerce ministry ratified its production sharing contract with state partner CUCBM, covering 1,072 square kilometres at Enhong and Laochang in Yunnan. Drilling of the first exploration wells there began in November 2003.

The company also bought a US asset. Under a deal dated 31 December 2002 it acquired Newark Valley Oil & Gas from North American Oil and Gas for 1.6 million restricted shares and $600,000 in instalments, gaining about 147,535 net acres of undeveloped Montana rights. The filing reporting the deal said the financial statements would follow later.

2004-2005: Missed deadlines and a restructure

In December 2004 the company had to renegotiate its farmout agreements with Phillips China on the Qinnan and Shouyang blocks, buying more time to finish its work. It was the first of many missed drilling deadlines. The same week, overseas investors put in $10.25 million for units of two shares plus a warrant, money meant for horizontal drilling in 2005. In January 2005 the escrow backing its drilling obligations was restated, and would grow by $1.6 million to $2.6 million if the first horizontal well was late.

In February 2005 it sold the Montana leases and royalties for $1.135 million, leaving a pure bet on China. In June shareholders approved moving the China business into a Bermuda subsidiary, Far East Energy (Bermuda), Ltd. In September it raised $10.9 million selling 12.1 million shares, and in October CUCBM agreed to extend the Yunnan exploration deadline to June 2007.

2006-2008: New deadlines and a World Bank investor

Another private placement followed in July 2006, raising $8.94 million from 6.6 million shares at about $1.35. In April 2007 three agreements extended the exploration periods on Shouyang, Qinnan and Yunnan, and China's commerce ministry approved all three in June.

In August 2007 the International Finance Corporation, the World Bank's private-sector arm, bought $15 million of stock, 11.5 million shares plus warrants at $2.61. In March 2008 the company appointed Phil Christian, a BP operations manager, as president and chief operating officer of the Bermuda subsidiary to get the wells drilled.

2009-2011: Falling prices and a rolled note

In March 2009 Arrow Energy paid $10 million for an exchangeable note from the Bermuda subsidiary plus warrants over 7.4 million shares, and was to receive 75.25% of the company's rights in Qinnan. In August 2009 Beijing extended the Shouyang and Yunnan exploration periods to June 2011.

Then the raisings came quickly at falling prices: units at $2.12 for five shares and a warrant in December 2009 (roughly 42 cents a share), $0.43 a share in March 2010, and in August 2010 Macquarie placed 105.5 million shares at $0.33, roughly doubling the share count. In June 2010 a gas sales contract for Shouyang gas was signed between CUCBM and a Shanxi provincial gas group, the first firm route to market. In March 2011 shares sold at $0.5025 through Religare, a higher price than the last. That month Arrow's note, now held by Dart Energy, fell due and could not be repaid, so maturity was pushed to September 2011.

2011-2013: Bank debt and the 13% notes

In December 2011 Standard Chartered provided a $25 million facility to the Bermuda subsidiary, guaranteed by the parent, for Shouyang costs. The initial term was nine months. In 2012 the company handed back the Enhong block, keeping the 483 square kilometre Laochang block, and Shouyang's exploration period was extended to June 2015.

Unable to repay at maturity, the company won short deferrals from the bank in November and December 2012 while it arranged a refinancing. In January 2013 it raised $60 million of senior secured notes with warrants, paying 13% in cash or 14.5% in more notes, due January 2016. In December 2013 CUCBM extended Shouyang exploration to June 2016, but only in return for a commitment to drill at least 39 more wells.

2014-2015: Month-by-month reprieves and liquidation

From November 2014 the bank deferred interest as well as principal, and extended the loan again and again, often a month or less at a time, thirteen extensions in all. In 2015 the company took unsecured working capital loans of $1.4 million (February), $4 million (April) and another $4 million (June). In September a $16.3 million facility was arranged, $8.8 million of it used to repay those three loans. In October Standard Chartered sold its position to the same lender group, which extended maturity to March 2016.

On 10 November 2015 Far East Energy filed for Chapter 7 liquidation after failing to sell or restructure itself, placing its assets in a trustee's hands. The filing defaulted about $123 million of debt: $23.2 million on the bank facility, $10.8 million on the working capital loans and $89.1 million on the notes. Both remaining officers ceased to hold office, and the company ended without commercial production.

Written from the 46 story beats below (2002 to 10 Nov 2015), which come from the company's own announcements and filings.

Beat by beat

The events that changed the company's story, in plain English, each written against everything known about the company at the time. The dot shows whether it was good, bad or neutral for shareholders.

shares on issue market cap (log scale)

2015346m shares

  1. 10 Nov

    Far East Energy filed for Chapter 7 liquidation on 10 November 2015 after failing to sell or restructure itself, handing control to a trustee. The filing defaulted the 2011 facility ($23.2 million), the working capital loans ($10.8 million) and the notes ($89.1 million), and the CEO and CFO left immediately.

    bankruptcy or receivership

    346m sh
  2. 7 Oct

    Standard Chartered sold its position out of the 2011 facility to the same lender group behind the working capital loans, and the new holders extended the maturity to March 2016. The original bank was gone; the company's fate now sat with a single group of distressed lenders.

    material agreement

    346m sh
  3. 30 Sept

    A $16.3 million unsecured facility was arranged, of which $8.8 million refinanced the February, April and June working capital loans in full. The other $7.5 million was left for approved working capital use, with $500,000 requested at once.

    debt financing

    346m sh
  4. 11 Sept

    A thirteenth and final extension carried the bank loan to 8 October 2015 with interest deferred once more - the last of a year of month-by-month reprieves.

    debt default or forbearance

    346m sh
  5. 2 July

    A twelfth extension carried the bank loan to 4 September 2015, interest deferred.

    debt default or forbearance

    346m shUS$10.4m
  6. 29 June

    The February working capital loan was extended a second time and a third $4 million unsecured facility was taken from the same lenders - the company now rolling three separate stopgap loans at once.

    debt financing

    346m shUS$6.9m
  7. 2 June

    An eleventh extension moved the bank loan to 3 July 2015, interest deferred again.

    debt default or forbearance

    346m shUS$6.9m
  8. 1 May

    A tenth extension carried the bank loan to 1 June 2015 with interest deferred.

    debt default or forbearance

    346m shUS$10.4m
  9. 9 Apr

    A second unsecured working capital facility, this one $4 million over six months, was drawn from the same lender group six weeks after the first.

    debt financing

    346m shUS$10.4m
  10. 1 Apr

    A ninth extension moved the bank loan to 30 April 2015, interest deferred again.

    debt default or forbearance

    346m shUS$10.4m
  11. 27 Feb

    With the bank loan unpayable, the company took a $1.4 million three-month unsecured working capital loan from a group of lenders - borrowing to keep the lights on rather than to drill.

    debt financing

    346m shUS$13.8m
  12. 19 Feb

    An eighth extension carried the unpaid principal and interest to 31 March 2015.

    debt default or forbearance

    346m shUS$13.8m
  13. 15 Jan

    Another month bought, to 13 February 2015, with the interest deferred once more.

    debt default or forbearance

    346m shUS$13.8m
  14. 5 Jan

    Principal and the deferred interest were pushed again, to 15 January 2015 - a fortnight at a time.

    debt default or forbearance

    346m shUS$13.8m

2014346m shares · US$20.8m market cap

  1. 28 Nov

    For the first time the bank deferred the interest itself, not just the principal: the November payment was rolled into a new maturity of 31 December 2014. The company had stopped being able to service the loan at all.

    debt default or forbearance

    346m shUS$20.8m

2013346m shares · US$41.5m market cap

  1. 12 Dec

    CUCBM extended Shouyang exploration to June 2016 over 1,103 square kilometres, but only in exchange for a commitment to drill at least 39 more wells - more time bought with spending the company had no obvious way to fund.

    material agreement

    346m shUS$41.5m
  2. 18 Jan

    Far East Energy raised $60 million by selling senior secured notes of its Bermuda subsidiary plus warrants, at 13% cash interest or 14.5% if paid in more notes, maturing January 2016. It cleared the immediate bank problem, but committed a company with no revenue to a hard three-year deadline at a punishing rate. Those notes are the largest claim in its 2015 liquidation.

    capital raising announcement

    345m shUS$20.7m

2012345m shares · US$34.5m market cap

  1. 20 Dec

    Standard Chartered granted another short deferral of principal and interest to mid-January while the company finished documenting a private placement of senior secured notes - the bank lending against a refinancing that had not closed yet.

    debt default or forbearance

    345m shUS$34.5m
  2. 28 Nov

    Unable to repay at maturity, the company got Standard Chartered to push both the facility's termination date and the payment of all accrued interest out three weeks to 19 December 2012.

    debt default or forbearance

    345m shUS$37.9m
  3. 11 July

    The Shouyang exploration period was extended to June 2015 with Chinese government approval - the block that carried the gas sales contract and the bank loan now had three more years to deliver.

    material agreement

    345m shUS$58.6m
  4. 21 June

    Beijing approved a deal under which Far East Energy handed back the Enhong block in Yunnan and kept the 483 square kilometre Laochang block, with more time to explore it. Ten years after signing for 1,072 square kilometres, the company was giving half of it back.

    material agreement

    345m shUS$62.0m

2011342m shares · US$82.1m market cap

  1. 2 Dec

    Standard Chartered provided a $25 million facility to the Bermuda subsidiary, guaranteed by the parent, for Shouyang project costs - the company's first bank debt and, over the next four years, the obligation it spent most of its energy refinancing. The initial term was just nine months.

    debt financing

    342m shUS$82.1m
  2. 14 Mar

    Dart Energy exchanged $6.8 million of its $10 million note into 14,315,789 shares at $0.475 and sold them. The remaining $3.2 million principal plus about $1.08 million of interest was extended from March 2011 to September 15, 2011.

    capital raising announcement

    291m shUS$169m
  3. 11 Mar

    Far East agreed to sell shares at $0.5025 each in a registered direct offering through placement agent Religare. It expected $15-20 million in net proceeds for coalbed methane drilling, completion and testing in China.

    material agreement

    291m shUS$169m

2010

  1. 20 Aug

    Macquarie placed 105.5 million shares at $0.33 - a raise so large relative to the company that it roughly doubled the share count, at a third of the price paid a year earlier.

    material agreement

  2. 16 June

    A gas sales contract was signed for coalbed methane from the Shouyang block, between state partner CUCBM and a Shanxi provincial gas group - the first firm route to market for gas Far East Energy had been drilling for since 2003.

    material agreement

  3. 9 Mar

    Three months later the company raised again, selling stock and warrants at $0.43 a share through Rodman & Renshaw. The price kept falling and the raises kept coming.

    material agreement

2009

  1. 23 Dec

    Far East Energy sold units of five shares plus a two-share warrant at $2.12 through Pritchard Capital in a registered offering off its shelf - roughly 42 cents a share, a fraction of the $2.61 the World Bank's investment arm had paid two years earlier.

    material agreement

  2. 27 Aug

    China's commerce ministry approved extensions taking the exploration periods on both the Shouyang and the Yunnan blocks out to June 2011, buying nearly two more years to prove up gas.

    material agreement

  3. 16 Mar

    Far East Energy brought in Australian coalbed methane producer Arrow Energy as a partner: Arrow paid $10 million for an exchangeable note issued by the Bermuda subsidiary plus warrants over 7.4 million shares, and was to receive 75.25% of the company's rights in the Qinnan block. Cash and a credible operating partner at the depth of the financial crisis - but it handed away three quarters of one of its three blocks.

    capital raising announcement

2008

  1. 13 Mar

    Phil Christian, a BP operations manager with Russian project experience, was appointed president, chief operating officer and country manager of the Bermuda subsidiary - a heavyweight operator brought in to get the China wells drilled.

    director officer appointment

2007

  1. 27 Aug

    The World Bank's International Finance Corporation bought $15 million of stock - 11.5 million shares plus warrants at $2.61 - putting a development-finance institution on the register. The most credible endorsement the company ever received, and its largest single cheque to that point.

    material agreement

  2. 28 June

    China's commerce ministry approved all three exploration-period extensions signed in April, giving Far East Energy legally effective extra time on every one of its blocks.

    material agreement

  3. 27 Apr

    Three separate modification agreements were signed to extend the exploration periods on the Shouyang, Qinnan and Yunnan production sharing contracts, all subject to Chinese government approval - a company-wide reset of every deadline it had missed.

    material agreement

2006

  1. 7 July

    Far East Energy raised $8.94 million selling 6.6 million shares privately at about $1.35, paying 6.75% in fees. Another year, another placement, with no revenue yet in sight.

    capital raising announcement

2005

  1. 26 Oct

    Far East Energy got its Yunnan partner CUCBM to extend the phase-two exploration deadline at Enhong and Laochang all the way to June 2007, subject to Chinese government approval - the same slippage now affecting its second block as well as its first.

    material agreement

  2. 26 Sept

    Far East Energy raised $10.9 million selling 12.1 million shares privately, promising to register the shares within 60 days and to get its stock onto the American Stock Exchange within 180 days.

    capital raising announcement

  3. 2 June

    Shareholders approved moving essentially all the China business - the CUCBM production sharing contracts and related agreements - into a new Bermuda subsidiary, Far East Energy (Bermuda), Ltd. Every later contract, loan and default in this story sits at that subsidiary rather than the Nevada parent.

    material agreement

  4. 7 Feb

    Far East Energy sold its Montana leases and royalties for $1.135 million, closing out the US asset experiment three years after buying it. From here the company was a pure bet on Chinese coalbed methane.

    asset acquisition disposition

  5. 21 Jan

    The escrow securing Far East Energy's drilling obligations to Phillips China was restated to run to end-2005, and to grow by $1.6 million to $2.6 million if the company failed to drill its first horizontal well on time. Missing the deadline would now cost real cash.

    material agreement

2004

  1. 27 Dec

    Overseas investors subscribed $10.25 million for 6.4 million units of two shares plus a warrant exercisable at $2.50, with $820,000 of commissions and 1.5 million agent warrants on top. The money was earmarked for horizontal coalbed methane drilling in China in 2005.

    capital raising announcement

  2. 23 Dec

    Far East Energy signed a second amendment to its Phillips China farmouts on the Qinnan and Shouyang blocks. It extended phase one to January 31, 2005 and phase two to December 31, 2005, reworked the horizontal-well programme, and kept a $1 million escrow that rises to $2.6 million if the first phase-two well is not drilled by June 30, 2005.

    material agreement

2003

  1. 24 Dec

    This amendment, filed December 2003, reports the Newark Valley deal dated 31 December 2002: Far East Energy bought Newark Valley Oil & Gas from North American Oil and Gas for 1.6 million restricted shares plus $600,000 paid in three instalments ($100,000 at closing, $200,000 after five months, $300,000 after twelve). It brought about 147,535 net acres of undeveloped Montana rights, mostly federal leases, and gave North American piggyback registration rights on 800,000 shares. The filing says the financial statements and pro forma information were not yet ready and would follow in a later amendment.

    asset acquisition disposition

  2. 12 Nov

    Far East Energy began drilling its first exploration wells in the Enhong-Laochang coalbed methane blocks in Yunnan, moving from contract-signing to actual drilling for the first time.

    drilling progress report

  3. 13 Jan

    China's commerce ministry ratified the production sharing contract Far East Energy had signed with state partner CUCBM in January 2002, making its rights over 1,072 square kilometres at Enhong and Laochang in Yunnan legally effective. The company's core asset was now secure on paper; proving it held gas was the harder part.

    asset acquisition disposition

2002

  1. 7 June

    Far East Energy signed a Chinese joint venture with Panjiang Coal-Electricity to capture coal mine methane from six working coal mines across 120 square kilometres, agreeing to pay Panjiang $3.3 million over three years for the rights. Its first operating position in China alongside the exploration contracts.

    asset acquisition disposition